Speaker Pelosi will soon ask at least 12 of the conservative Blue Dog Democrats in the U.S. House, who voted against the Health Care bill in December, to fall on their proverbial swords and cast a 'yea' ballot for the Senate bill.
Among the 37 targets of her party's pressure will be local Democrats like Louisiana's Charlie Melancon and Mississippi's Gene Taylor. And, asking them to switch sides could be potentially fatal electorally. Melancon is running double- digits behind Republican David Vitter for the U.S. Senate, and both he and Taylor represent districts that went for John McCain by substantial margins and are difficult for a Democrat to hold under the best of circumstances.
The same can be said of the Speaker's other targets in her party's conservative wing, who represent GOP-leaning seats in a year when the tide is distinctly against the Democrats. In other words, it is not unreasonable to expect that she would be quite open to providing substantial political cover to the switched votes as the reconciliation bill "fixes" are negotiated. After all, its just a few more pages in the over 2300 page bill she and her leaders posted on the web Sunday night.
Pelosi, in the end, has no choice. The 11 votes that Congressman Bart Stupak of Michigan holds are firm against supporting any legislation that does not include a firm prohibiition against any insurance policy in the federal exchanges possessing abortion services. Under the reconciliation bill, the Speaker has no leverage to include those prohibitions, and even if she could, they would die from Senatorial opposition from Democratic pro-choice activists in the Upper Chamber like Barbara Boxer and Barbara Mikulski--critical votes to pass the reconciliation fixes.
The U.S. House will not pass the Senate Health Care bill unless certain measures are addressed for the next decade, including a suspension in the Cadallic Tax for labor unions (a make-it or break-it demand of pro-labor congressmen), extension of the so-called "Cornhusker Kickback" of full Federal funding of Medicaid expansion to every state in the nation, and a few other less publicized changes of funding policy that have drawn public ire.
In all the process-conversation of Reconciliation, Democrats have often failed to emphasize that the plan for the House is to pass the Senate Health Care bill, approved under normal rules by 60 votes already, and then the House could pass its funding changes as part of a budgetary reconciliation vote that can not be blocked by the GOP's 41st new vote, Scott Brown.
Most of the proposed changes are budgetary matters of taxes and spending (such as the eight year suspension of the Cadillac Tax for labor unions) and follow GOP precedent on the Bush tax cuts--which passed under reconciliation rules when the Administration was able to only garner 58 Senatorial votes initially--and 50 votes for their second phase two years later.
With Republicans having used reconciliation for tax cuts and yearly for budgetary spending (as with any Congress, the reason reconciliation exists is to pass a yearly budget without a filibuster), the GOP's options to block the bill under a Senate Rule vote are limited.
Still, that does not mean that Pelosi will get the votes she needs for the overall bill, unless she is willing to address three areas that are of prime concern to swing voters in the reconciliation bill, and could help defend endangered Democrats in November.
First, nearly a quarter of seniors entering Medicare eligibility sign up for the Medicare Advantage program. Despite the added cost, the private insurance option under Medicare is widely popular. Doctors who refused to accept patients under the limited repayments of Medicare generally do take patients under Medicare Advantage, if for no other reason that they fear losing conventional service from Insurance providers. And, the repayments for Doctor visits are better.
Consequently, the program is universally popular in swing districts with large proportions of elderly voters. And, old people vote, as all Congressmen know. For that reason, in fact, Florida US Senator Bill Nelson had the residents of three South Florida counties grandfathered in to the program, a special deal that has drawn national condemnation.
The simple thing to do politically is to not cut Medicare at all, thus reducing the political danger to Democrats of cutting a popular entitlement. However, just as the so-called "Cornhusker Kickback" on Medicaid funding has been extended to all 50 states in the reconciliation bill, so then, grandfather all current recipients of Medicare Advantage.
Speaking of Medicare, while funding will be increasing from Federal coffers under the compromise to 150% of the poverty level, many of the program mandates still make the bill very unpopular in the halls of state legislators. California Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger, an inital supporter of the President's plan, turned against the Health Care proposal for this reason. So why not include a provision allowing automatic wavers for state legislators to re craft the Medicaid program to their state's specifications--as long as it meets the coverage goals now in place for the S-Chip legislation, 150% of poverty.
Since such a change would be up to the State legislators, federalism critiques of conservative Democrats would be minimized, yet liberals seeking a greater federal role would not likewise gain damage in their home districts. The legislation would be in place, unless other changed by the state capitols.
Lastly, the most poignant critique of the legislation by Conservatives and Liberals is the individual mandate. It forces many struggling families to pay for health insurance with dollars they frankly do not have. And since, under the Senate bill, subsidies tend to phase out for families making more than $42,000, this appears to be a tax increase on the middle class--something the President specifically pledged not to do.
And, as these subsidies are directed to Insurance Companies, few people see their benefits in their pocketbooks. As such, steal a popular Republican idea. For families making less than $250,000, give a refundable tax credit of $6000 per family to help pay health insurance costs, if they do not receive insurance from their employers.
This has a huge fiscal note, but it empowers many middle class taxpayers caught in the system, and begins the fiscally necessary process of detaching health care from employment, a necessary move for eventual cost control. It also provides wavering Democrats with the talking point, "We gave you the biggest middle class tax cut in history..."
These three proposals are not cheap, but in the end, the protestations of fiscal rectitude are something that has been overblown in this legislation. The real cost of Heath Care Reform is closer to $2.1 Trillion over ten years. These proposals would add roughly $500 billion to the price tag, but would equally help with long term competition and therefore cost control.
They also protect Democrats from the three strongest charges that Republicans would have in the fall, and maybe necessary if Speaker Pelosi has any hope of getting 216 votes for Health Care reform. Regardless, if these changes are unworkable, they would expire in the 10 years under reconciliation rules--just as the Bush Tax Cuts soon will. Consider the modifications to be transition costs to full Health Care Coverage rather than transition prices that midwife the election of a Republican Congress.
Christopher Tidmore and David Gereighty are on the radio in morning drive from 7-8 AM on WSLA 1560 AM New Orleans and KKAY 1590 AM in Baton Rouge, archived and streamed online atwww.gtmorning.com.
How about "There is something THE PEOPLE can do for the economy... make the government LESS of a constricting influence on the private sector ... not MORE...
Written by
on 3/17/2010
REPORT SPAM OR ABUSE
There IS something Obama can do for the economy ... make the Federal government LESS of a drain on the private sector ... not MORE... Written by kpf
on 3/17/2010
REPORT SPAM OR ABUSE
What a shame, not even a stir……….. Chinese Peace Keeping Mission Troops walking our streets.... Folks just sit there, read that, and have nothing to say…… They sit back numb, waiting for half time…. Of course we have this health care bill they are trying to pass that is unsustainable where the incomes of folks are concerned…. Teachers getting laid off all across the nation…. So much for education….. And of course the joblessness,. Nothing Obama could do for or is to blame for where that is concerned, because it’s been going on and on and on….. And we have Iraq, and Afghanistan going on…. Lots n’ lots of additional ‘home grown’ “volunteer” national guard style boys n’ girls over there that, when they do come home, have no jobs and probably no teachers to help them ‘re-vocate’…. So what do they do? Ehhhh, perhaps in a feeble attempt to keep the Repo Man from sending his Chinese Peace Keeping Mission Troops to walk our streets, first we use the returning troops as cops and enforcers… More tickets, more fines, more jailing, so that they can ‘earn their daily bread’ but overlooking the root of the problems we face….. They will be about as helpless here as they are over there to really change anything…. Sort of like Russia/Afghanistan bring down the wall all over again….. And then it comes on down to some people that want to take the Kamikaze approach like we had with the guy flying his airplane into an IRS building, or the guy that went to ‘shoot up’ the wall space around the Pentagon, sure, there are going to be quite a few more of them.. Such a waste…. And there will be those that cling to their guns thinking that’s what makes them ‘American’ but when it comes on down to it, what are they fighting? Oh, I almost forgot, to protect their homes and their freedoms….. Yeah, real nice John Wayne – Davie Crockett attitude but really, who is going to tend their wounds? None of the doctors or nurses…. They have all been trained Pavlov style to report all gunshot wounds…. And of course if they don’t, well, they lose their homes…. They will have our ‘policing’ troops to thank for that….. So really and truly, resistance will be futile…. Because as a whole, we are willing to let the Government do what it wants…. Oh sure, we may pizz and moan a little…. Jump on our little bloggy boards and rant at the wind… But when it comes time to really supporting good or common interest…. Well, folks are simply going to put their own first… And collectively get dragged down by the stone… And why? The Superbia – Pride ,,,,, Invidia – Envy,,,,,, Ira – Anger,,,,, Avaritia – Avarice (jealousy),,,,, Tristia – Sadness,,,, Gula – Gluttony,,,, Luxuria – Lust,,,,, and the Sunday: Monday: Tuesday: Wednesday: Thursday: Friday: and Saturday OF IT ALL………………… Ahhhh, such a sad a disillusioned mob……. Written by
on 3/17/2010
REPORT SPAM OR ABUSE
May as well crash it all down and start over from scratch I suppose.... Gon'na be kind of interesting watching all the Chinese Peace Keeping Mission Troops walking our streets.... Oh well, I guess it's what we all wanted deep down inside...... Ahhh the thrill of the roller coaster ride. Pretty soon perhaps every one will get the chance to stand up equally and equally become HEROS!!!!!!! I hear the pastures in Alexandria Virgina are 6 foot deep with 'em!!! Yeah, that Charlie Boy, he's my kind of guy.... Oooooh, I think I'm getting a man crush... Written by
on 3/16/2010
REPORT SPAM OR ABUSE
Charlie Melancon should support Mary Landrieu and Louisiana and vote for the Health Care Reform Bill. Written by David Quidd
on 3/16/2010
REPORT SPAM OR ABUSE
THIS WAS A PRETTY INTERESTING STORY, SORT OF PUTS THINGS INTO PERSPECTIVE PLAIN AND SIMPLE I SUPPOSE - - - -- - - - - Where a Meal Can Cost a Fortune, 99¢ Pizza Catches On - - By: MANNY FERNANDEZ – New York Times - Published: March 15, 2010 - The signs at the corner of Ninth Avenue and West 41st Street have an unbelievable, you-gotta-be-kidding quality, like free beer or affordable housing — 99¢ Fresh Pizza. Like many things in New York City, they are also too good to be true. They are off by a penny, as one slice actually costs one dollar…. Seven days a week, 24 hours a day, New Yorkers stand at the outdoor counter of 99¢ Fresh Pizza and pay as much for a plain slice as they did for a subway fare in 1986. At $1.50, the fee to use the sidewalk A.T.M. nearby is more expensive…. This being a city with a 10.4 percent unemployment rate in January, this being a recession, there is no such thing as change that is spare. Customers, taking the signs at their word, have been known to ask for a penny back after paying with a dollar bill. … “I give them penny,” explained Mohammad Hossain, a manager at the pizza shop. … No pennies change hands one block down Ninth Avenue, at West 40th Street, where the competition posted signs of their own: “Pizza, $1.00 per slice, tax included.” Postal workers, teenagers and businessmen step into the 24-hour 2 Bros. Pizza, $5 bills in hand. Allegiances have formed. Trash has been talked. A cabdriver said he preferred 99¢ Fresh over 2 Bros., because it was easier to find street parking outside 99¢ Fresh. A patron of 2 Bros. prefers their sauce over the sauce up the block. … Each establishment has the same daily special: Two slices and a can of soda for $2.75, which is what most places charge for a single slice. There is indoor seating at 2 Bros., but none at 99¢ Fresh. There is grated parmesan on the counter at 99¢ Fresh, but none at 2 Bros. … Asked who opened first, Mr. Hossain was adamant, perhaps even offended: “This is first! This is first!” … In New York City, the domain of the $1,000 omelet (Norma’s, at Le Parker Meridien Hotel) and the $41 burger (Old Homestead Steakhouse), the dollar wars between 99¢ Fresh and 2 Bros. are an unlikely development. … The shops are two of a growing number of New York delis and pizzerias offering $1 slices, a phenomenon that has delighted, dismayed and disturbed pizza lovers, food bloggers and rival pizzeria owners while defying a basic fundamental of the city’s economy — charging as much as you can whenever and wherever you can. … About 15 eateries around the city now sell dollar slices of pizza. The owners of 99¢ Fresh and 2 Bros. have turned bargain pizza into a business model: There are four 99¢ Fresh shops in Manhattan, and four 2 Bros., too. Next month, 99¢ fresh will open its fifth shop on 34th Street near Third Avenue. … While dollar menus have become a staple of many fast-food restaurants in New York, the low-cost pizzerias base their entire restaurants around the idea. … Pizza experts said the rise of dollar pizza was an economy-driven counterpoint to New York’s more celebrated high-end pizza. Last year, Di Fara Pizza in Brooklyn, widely considered one of the best in the city because each pie is handmade by the owner using imported ingredients from Italy, raised the price of a plain slice to $5. … “I don’t think a drunk college student cares about whether there’s San Marzano tomatoes on their slice,” Jason Feirman, 25, who writes a pizza blog called I Dream of Pizza, said of the $1 pizza trend. “It’s a good business model. They’re not catering to food blogs. The idea is to turn out these pizzas as fast as they can.” … Theories abound as to how an establishment can sell such cheap food in such an expensive city. Dollar pizza shops have been accused of using frozen dough, skimping on the cheese and sauce and cutting slices too small…. “I think that it’s great for the people that aren’t interested in high-quality product,” said Margaret Mieles, Di Fara’s manager, of dollar-slice establishments. … The owners of 2 Bros. and 99¢ Fresh contend that their slices are made fresh with quality ingredients and that they make their own dough and their own pizza sauce. They describe the dollar-slice business as a kind of public service, with minimal profit margins. … In 2008, when the first 2 Bros. Pizza opened on St. Marks Place in the East Village, the owners decided to have a grand-opening dollar-slice special. It was so popular, they made it permanent. … “Financially, it doesn’t make a lot of sense, but it’s part of our brand,” Eli Halali, 26, one of the two brothers who co-own 2 Bros. Pizza, said as he stood next to sacks of General Mills enriched flour in the East Village shop…. Abdul Mohammad, the owner of the 99¢ Fresh chain, said there was no secret to his formula. His stores are in small spaces with low rent in pedestrian-heavy locations that can support a 400-pie day. “If I sell like 20 pies, 30 pies, I cannot pay the rent, pay the employees,” he said. “My rent is cheap. If I pay $15,000 to $20,000 rent, I can’t do dollar slices.” … He said that he made roughly 15 cents to 20 cents profit per slice and that it was not unusual for one 99¢ Fresh location to produce up to 450 pies a day. His pizza is so cheap some customers treat him like a wholesaler, ordering dozens of pies in the morning and selling the slices elsewhere — for $2 each. … At lunchtime the other day at Ninth Avenue and 41st Street, 13 men and women stood on the sidewalk outside 99¢ Fresh, impatiently ordering and impatiently eating slices amid the ambiance of ungentrified Hell’s Kitchen: idling delivery trucks near the rear of the Port Authority Bus Terminal, a barking dog named Leo someone tied up down the block, a prostitute who hurried by saying something about $150 for a half-hour and a bearded homeless man with a cane who spoke loudly to himself about the size of the average bear. He ate two slices. … Some rave about the slices at the two chains, saying they are as good or better than more expensive slices, while others are only mildly impressed, or flat-out unimpressed. No one, however, complains about the price…. Last April, Adam Kuban, 35, the managing editor of SeriousEats.com and the founder of the pizza blog Slice, had what he called a “cheap-slice showdown” between 99¢ Fresh and 2 Bros. In part because of its “better hole structure” in the crust, Mr. Kuban declared 2 Bros. as the winner. Mr. Feirman of I Dream of Pizza would have voted differently, with 99¢ Fresh being his preference. … “Is it the best pizza out there? It’s not,” Mr. Kuban said in an interview, referring to both 99¢ Fresh and 2 Bros. “But for somebody who just wants bread and sauce and cheese, it’ll do you right.” … The inspiration for the trend, said Mr. Mohammad, considered the dollar-slice trailblazer, was not the cabbies, the tourists or the late-night drinkers of Hell’s Kitchen, but another demographic entirely: the homeless, who used a 24-hour drop-in center at Ninth Avenue and 41st Street. … “If they want to buy Chinese food, they need $4,” Mr. Mohammad said. “For a slice, it’s $2.50. I think about these people. I say, ‘I want to do something for these people.’ ” … A version of this article appeared in print on March 16, 2010, on page A19 of the New York edition……………… Written by
on 3/16/2010
REPORT SPAM OR ABUSE
Because basically all you are looking at is people's greed... "You cannot miss or lose what you never had"..... Take the U.S. Post Office for instance... Pizzing and moaning how it lost 8 billion dollars or something like that last year, or last quarter, or last week, who really knows? Anyways, it says it 'lost' 8 billion dollars because more people are making payments through 'online' transactions rather than buying stamps.... Oh, I get it, the P.O. LOST $8 billion because it didn't 'extract' that from people.... So now, to make up for what they wanted to make but didn't get to make, they are going to raise the price of postage and the cost to the consumer.... Makes a lot of fuggin sense don't it? Sort of like Kp's stupid conjecture that water should cost more in a desert.. What a lame philosophy...... Written by
on 3/15/2010
REPORT SPAM OR ABUSE
Multi-trillions? Pay 'em with 'Lever' notes... Who cares? Need a gallong of milk? 'Lever' notes.... Dozen eggs? 'Lever' notes.... And if the doctor is on a 6 month waiting list to get his new Mercedes Benz? Who gives a shit? Lot's of folks are on 2 year waiting lists to get lungs, kidneys, hearts, eyes, wutever... It's one thing to have to come up with a wheel barrow of money to buy a loaf of bread, it is quite another to have all the money you need and have to stand in line and wait just like every other person when it comes time to purchase a luxury item, or some stupid 'fad' toy at christmas time that comes out and is totally sold out a week before you can get to the store.... Who cares? At least folks won't starve with 'Lever' notes. Now getting them, that's another subject all in itself... Soooo, I guess we need to create jobs for all the folks that will all of a sudden have to earn a living... Nothing wrong with picking up litter in a park.... Shouldn't mean you have to have a prisoner doing it for you and costing you money at the same time in the form of tax dollars.... Just shuffle some 'Lever' notes that worker's way........ Who cares? Written by
on 3/15/2010
REPORT SPAM OR ABUSE
The bottom line of this bill passing will depend on the stranglehold of Pelosi and the liberals who won't listen to the people. Passing this will be at their peril. WE want health reform but to jam this multitrillion bill down our throats is just wrong...you will be sorry. Written by Momlee
on 3/15/2010
REPORT SPAM OR ABUSE
Whomever votes for this rediculously irresponsible bill will be ousted. We will never forget it Landrieu!!!! YOU ARE TOAST Written by NANA
on 3/15/2010
REPORT SPAM OR ABUSE
At this point, it is all moot really.... Change is painful, but change we MUST have. If this health care bill is what it takes to tear down the wall, then let the rumble in the jungle begin!!! Burn this biotch of a crooked way of government we currently have down to the ground and start it all over..... But have a plan to make things right, and do not crush the people's freedoms, liberties, and rights at the same time.... Oh, and by the way ABORTION IS MURDER ..... AND I AM CONCERNED ABOUT THE RIGHTS OF THE UNBORN ...... SO ABORT THAT PORTION OF SOME KIND OF WEAK ARGUMENT FROM ANY DISCUSSION FOR NOW AND GET ON WITH THE SHOW!! Written by
on 3/15/2010
REPORT SPAM OR ABUSE
Charlie Melancon has to vote for Health Care reform if he wants to defeat David Vitter. Those strongly opposed to health care reform will never vote for Melancon even if he votes against the Senate Bill. Those who support health care reform will divert their money and support to other Democratic Senate candidates in other states who do support health care reform. If Melancon wants to win, he will vote for the Senate Bill. Written by David Quidd
on 3/15/2010
REPORT SPAM OR ABUSE